Brewbirds wrote:RickBeer wrote:CowboyKyle wrote: I think anyone who wants to continue brewing beyond the first 6 months to a year likely moves into partial mash and All Grain... right? I plan to. I am sure it is the natural evolution for most.
3 years, all extract brewing. Steeped grains, LME, hops. Just cloned Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter and Fat Tire. Pick the method that produces beer that you enjoy. Homebrewing can be as complex or as simple as you like.
^^^^ THIS ^^^^
From all the posts I've read I got the impression that new brewers feel a sense of urgency and obligation to move into PM or all grain brewing.
I don't know if there is something not getting passed along that really good beer can be made by non-hme extracts or that there is still confusion about HME vs. extract in the way it gets explained to "brand new" brewers.
The greatest thing about home brewing as a hobby is precisely that it is so versatile and the final product is equally rewarding.
^^^ what they said ^^^
I started off around 20 years ago as AG right out of the box. Because back then extract came in a can and it was probably a year old. And it didn't make the best beer. I then too took a long brewing hiatus due to various reasons which you can find if you search old posts.
I came back with very little time to brew, so did HMEs and some extracts and steeps. I discovered that modern fresh bulk extracts are nothing at all like the stuff in a can was back in the "old days", and that I can make beer as good as my old AG days with them. Better actually because I'm a better brewer now from an overall process standpoint.
I now am back to doing some AG, some PMs, and still also extract batches and extract/steep batches - it all depends on how much time I had to brew.
If I gave you one of my extract or AG beers and didn't tell you which was which you likely wouldn't know.
AG is less expensive, but more time consuming. You can get more control with AG, but whether that matters really depends on what you are brewing, and you can brew a lot of things with PMs and modern extracts. Some styles that were impossible before - rye and munich based beers, or beers with authentic british/continental malt vibe for example - are no longer out of the realm of extract brewing.
I like spending the time doing AG/BIAB when I have it, but I like saving the time when I don't. My time saved is worth the extra money, as long as I'm making good beer.
So really, what it comes down to is brew however you like as long as you are getting the results you want.