Do experienced brewers bottle?

Vent, Rant, Chat or just talk about whatever is on your mind! Keep it civil though!

Moderators: BlackDuck, Beer-lord, LouieMacGoo, philm00x, gwcr

Scoper50
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 39
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2017 7:18 pm

Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by Scoper50 »

I've noticed just from lurking around here the past couple months that most of you experienced guys keg. But do any of you still prefer bottles even though it's more labor intensive? If you do, why?
User avatar
berryman
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 3279
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 5:16 pm
Location: Western NY

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by berryman »

Scoper50 wrote:I've noticed just from lurking around here the past couple months that most of you experienced guys keg. But do any of you still prefer bottles even though it's more labor intensive? If you do, why?
Scoper, I really like this question and have been waiting for someone to ask it for a long time. Not sure if I am qualified to be an experienced brewer, but maybe, started in 2009. I have thought heavy on kegging and with all the information and good help on here and other sites would be easy to do. But I still bottle and will explain why. I like a variety of different styles of beer and whenever the mood strikes me I change it out on any given night. I may go from a pale ale to a IPA, a stout or to a Belgian or a light wheat or many other styles of beer and I like them all. This is hard to do if you are committed to a few kegs of beer on tap. Don't get me wrong I love kegged and tap beer but just don't work for me. I also like to give out variety samples to my friends and bottle beer works better for that. On the down side, I really don't care for bottling day even though I have quite a good system going, but not my most fun part of brewing but still do it for the above reasons. Bottling is a PITA but I do it anyways..................
Happy Hound Brewery

“I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.”
― Thomas A. Edison
User avatar
John Sand
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 4310
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 9:01 pm
Location: Long Island NY

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by John Sand »

Berry makes a good point. I started small and simple, I think it is best. Brewing and bottling small batches is a good way to learn. I brewed 21 batches my first year but only 11 last year. My learning would have been slower in bigger batches, and I generally only have two styles available because that's what my kegerator holds. Progress at your own pace.
Making beer and stew for the Zombie Apocalypse.
Never mind, there it is.
bpgreen
Uber Brewer
Uber Brewer
Posts: 1966
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 9:50 pm

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by bpgreen »

I switched to kegging about the same time as I stated brewing 5 gallon batches (also about the time I got divorced).

In my case, it was more that I didn't like bottling that many bottles. I can transfer a 5 gallon batch to the keg in less time than I could bottle 2.4 gallons.
dbrowning
Fully Fermented
Fully Fermented
Posts: 384
Joined: Thu Aug 08, 2013 8:45 pm
Location: North Alabama

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by dbrowning »

I do both
Kegging most of my beers for about 2 years,
But I usually bottle the ones I drink slower.
higher alcohol beers, Stouts, Porters go in bottles
as well as anything that is going to require extended aging
because they would tie up a keg to long.
User avatar
BlackDuck
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 5156
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 7:49 am
Location: Canal Winchester, Ohio

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by BlackDuck »

Berryman makes a great point about having variety available when you bottle. That is so true. If you like to have a lot of variety available, bottling smaller batches is definitely the way to go. For me, I pretty much brew/drink pale ales, IPA's and German/Czech Pilsners. My keg system can run 4 kegs. But usually I'm only running 3. The 4th line is usually available if I want to try something different (I've got a Berliner Weiss on right now). If you're like berryman and like a lot of variety, bottling is smart. But if you're like me and happy with just a few beers available at any given time, kegging might work best. Either way, there's no right or wrong and really doesn't matter if you're new to brewing or an experienced guy. Bottling definitely as it's pro's and con's and so does kegging.
ANTLER BREWING
Drinking
#93 - Gerst Amber Ale
Conditioning and Carbing

Fermenting

On Deck
User avatar
RickBeer
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 3099
Joined: Thu Aug 08, 2013 1:21 pm
Location: Ann Arbor, Michigan (Go Blue!)

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by RickBeer »

CONSUMPTION comes into the equation also. Excluding beers that need a long time aging, people that keg tend to consume more beer than those that don't keg. In a normal week (outside the Michigan football season), my wife and I drink maybe 3 or 4 beers total per week. Given that your beer lines should be cleaned regularly (ideally every 2 weeks, no longer than every 4 weeks), I'd be putting in a lot of effort (and wasting some beer) if I cleaned my beer lines with that low consumption. Some drink 4 beers per day.

I also like BREADTH of beer selection - once was up to 14 different brews at once. Not going to have more than 4 on tap in most home environments.

With no kids at home any longer, my beer sits longer. I'm working through a large inventory, haven't brewed since April and probably won't until close to summer because I'm drinking year old beer now. Ideally, beer that doesn't require aging is consumed in 6 months or less.

So I don't see kegging in the near future for me.
I have over 9,000 posts on "another forum", which means absolutely nothing. Mr. Beer January 2014 Brewer of the Month with all the pomp and circumstance that comes with it...

Certificate in Brewing and Distillation Technology

Sites to find beer making supplies: Adventures in Homebrewing - Mr. Beer - MoreBeer
My Beer - click to reveal
Currently using 6 LBKs.

Beers I regularly brew:
Bell's Best Brown clone
Irish Hills Red - I call this "Ann Arbor Red"
Mackinac Island Red - I call this "Michigan Red"
Oatmeal Stout - I call this Not Fat, Stout - Oatmeal Stout

Bottled 5 gallons of Ann Arbor Red on 4/18/17. Bottled 5 gallons of Michigan Red on 5/8/17.

Brewed in 2017 - 22.13 gallons (19.91 in 2012, 48.06 in 2013, 61.39 in 2014, 84.26 in 2015,46.39 in 2016)
Brewed in lifetime - 282.14 gallons
Drinkable beer on hand -  13.58 cases, with 6.11 cases ready in May and early June.
Average cost per 12 pack through all beer brewed - $6.27(ingredients only)
User avatar
swenocha
Uber Brewer
Uber Brewer
Posts: 1991
Joined: Sun Aug 04, 2013 10:35 am

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by swenocha »

Much like what others have said... I'm in my 8th (I think) brewing year, and I've long talked of switching to kegging. But it's kind of a quandary for me, as I don't consume a lot of homebrew (or commercial beer, for that matter) these days. For various reasons, including just caloric reasons, I generally drink maybe 1-3 beers on a weekend, and usually none during the week (unless I'm meeting someone for tastings or happy hour, which doesn't happen a lot in these colder months). And the wife does wine (and a bit of cider) exclusively, and doesn't drink beer at all. And there are a ton of great commercial options in our market now. So, like Rick and others said, I don't really go through the volume of homebrew that cost- or time-justifies the switch. The quandary is, though, that I feel like I'd brew more (and drink more) if I kegged. I think that the majority of my falloff on brewing is just the tedious (to me) chore of bottling. So that leads me to consider switching, even though the earlier comments make it maybe not justified. And I'll agree that I like the variety that bottling provides. But I would love a quicker packaging day, and I'd also like to be out of the business of natural carbing and the trubby results that that brings. Yes, a real quandary...
Swenocha is a vast bastard of brewing knowledge - Wings_Fan_In_KC

Fermenting:
nada... zip...

Drinking:
nada... zip... maybe an N/A beer here and there...
User avatar
John Sand
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 4310
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 9:01 pm
Location: Long Island NY

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by John Sand »

Everyone has a story, this is a good discussion.
I think I drink less with kegs. With bottles, if I open one, I finish it. Open two, finish both. The keg lets me easily drink half a beer or a beer and a half.
Making beer and stew for the Zombie Apocalypse.
Never mind, there it is.
User avatar
Tabasco
Fully Fermented
Fully Fermented
Posts: 436
Joined: Sat Aug 10, 2013 9:45 am
Location: Long Island, NY

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by Tabasco »

bpgreen wrote: I can transfer a 5 gallon batch to the keg in less time than I could bottle 2.4 gallons.
Yah, I agree ... it's the time element that rules supreme for me ...
Banjo-guy
Braumeister
Braumeister
Posts: 811
Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 8:30 am

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by Banjo-guy »

I’ve been kegging for a few years. Bottling and kegging both have advantages and drawbacks. I have small 2.5 gallon kegs. That’s as big of a batch as I ever brew. I can’t even drink that small amount of beer.

When you keg,a certain amount of beer will sit in the line and go flat in a couple of days. I have 10 Foot serving lines and I lose about 2-3 ounces of beer unless I’m drinking everyday before the beer in the line has a chance to go flat. I always end up throwing the flat 2-3 ounces away if the keg hasn’t been used in 2 days.

Kegging is easier but not easy. I really don’t like the bottling process so I keg. Many times I’ll get impatient for a keg to kick and will bottle what’s left to free up a keg slot. It’s a good way to get some variety in the pipeline.
User avatar
BlackDuck
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 5156
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 7:49 am
Location: Canal Winchester, Ohio

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by BlackDuck »

Hey Banjo...I have 10 foot lines too. I know what you mean about the first couple of ounces being flat. Try bumping your psi up about a pound. This should take care of it. The first couple ounces will still pour flat, but the rest should be carbed enough to take care of it. This has worked for me and I never have to dump the first few ounces.
ANTLER BREWING
Drinking
#93 - Gerst Amber Ale
Conditioning and Carbing

Fermenting

On Deck
User avatar
berryman
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 3279
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 5:16 pm
Location: Western NY

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by berryman »

You guys will NEVER hear me say I enjoy or look forward to bottling day, :) but I do like the variety that can come with it. At most any given time I usually have 7 to 10 different beers to choose from. I do all 5 and 5 1/2 gal batches so that is somewhere between 50 and 60 bottles I clean and sanitize each time. I do rinse the bottles out good right after I pour a beer and before I even take a sip and I have so many bottles on hand that if they are stained or don't clean up good I toss them.
At one time I was seriously considering kegging and was doing research on the equipment needed and it wasn't a cost factor that stopped me, it just didn't fit into my style of home brewing. It actually doesn't take me that long to bottle a batch, but just the thought of doing it, not as fun as the planning and brewing part.
Happy Hound Brewery

“I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.”
― Thomas A. Edison
Scoper50
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 39
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2017 7:18 pm

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by Scoper50 »

Thanks for all the replies! I haven't really considered kegging until recently because I assumed that it was crazy expensive and that there would be a steep learning curve. But after watching some youtube videos I realized that it's not really that complicated. I'm' not sure if I'll make the leap anytime soon but it's good to get some perspective on the matter.
User avatar
MadBrewer
Braumeister
Braumeister
Posts: 973
Joined: Fri Aug 16, 2013 9:09 am

Re: Do experienced brewers bottle?

Post by MadBrewer »

John Sand wrote:I think I drink less with kegs. With bottles, if I open one, I finish it. Open two, finish both. The keg lets me easily drink half a beer or a beer and a half.
This is the case with me as well. Kegging allows me to drink just a sample here and there if I want which I enjoy doing. I like kegging for when I have company or a party, everyone really enjoys pouring their own beer and it's more of an experience.

The other hand I do miss bottles at times for more variety and portability. I do not bottle much at all, and going forward with some of the changes I have made with my brewing I will bottle even less. The only reason I would need to bottle is for competitions which for me are also getting very scarce. But I will say there is something about bottle conditioning for certain beers that kegging and force carbonation just doesn't do.
Brew Strong My Friends...
Post Reply