Mash and Boil for 250.00

There are so many gadgets and other stuff you can use to brew! Ask, learn and share what you got here!

Moderators: BlackDuck, Beer-lord, LouieMacGoo, philm00x, gwcr

Banjo-guy
Braumeister
Braumeister
Posts: 811
Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 8:30 am

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by Banjo-guy »

Entropy_Brewing wrote:Hello everyone! I've been involved in the conversations going on over on the FB page for the Mash and Boil, and Berryman invited me over here to check things out. I've had my M&B for about a year now and have done about 18 batches on it. I bought the unit originally to do small BIAB batch as test batches for my big 15gallon system, but found it was so easy to use I just kept going with 5 gallon batches. I have 3 young ones running around the house, so the ability to set up in the kitchen or back patio to brew has been a huge plus for me. I started off doing a standard mash with the "pour over" sparge during the mash, then installed a 12v brown pump and made an attempt at recirculation with limited success. I then stole the chugger pump off my big system hoping I could regulate things better in terms of flow rate. Having the larger pump and valve did seem to help some, but I still felt like I was constantly screwing with the flow. I was either flowing too much and risking overflowing the basket, or not enough and the grain bed would start to go dry. I brewed with a friend that had the robobrew rig, and it hit me exactly what was the purpose of the center drain pipe and was impressed as to how much easier it made the brew day. I decided to take matters into my own hands and build my own drain pipe set up. I used mostly off the shelf parts with a little machining required. With 2-3 handfuls of rice hulls and the drain pipe mod, I feel like I've greatly simplified my brew day, and picked up efficiency in the process. I can now set me pump at about 50-60% flow, and just let it run the entire mash without messing with it. I notice mash temps are also more stable now (fluctuate 2 to maybe 3 degrees) and I'm getting about 83% mash efficiency. Here are a couple vids of the set up, one showing the parts and other of a brew day with the drain pipe mod installed.
Welcome to the borg. You’ve done some really great mods to the M and B.
I’ve done three brews. All were 3 gallon biab. That’s all I plan on doing because I like the simplicity of it.
Watching your videos makes want to follow your approach but I think I’ll keep it simple. I only need 2.5 gallon batches most of the time.
User avatar
berryman
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 3279
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 5:16 pm
Location: Western NY

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by berryman »

Excellent Tyler, glad you came here and joined our forum The Beer Borg A small but good group of very knowable brewers with a lot of different ways of making beer. The M&B thread is just one of the many things discussed here. Check out the whole forum and looking forward to your insight on brewing.
Happy Hound Brewery

“I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.”
― Thomas A. Edison
User avatar
mashani
mashani
mashani
Posts: 6743
Joined: Sat Aug 10, 2013 11:57 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by mashani »

Banjo-guy wrote:Welcome to the borg. You’ve done some really great mods to the M and B.I’ve done three brews. All were 3 gallon biab. That’s all I plan on doing because I like the simplicity of it. Watching your videos makes want to follow your approach but I think I’ll keep it simple. I only need 2.5 gallon batches most of the time.
Yes, Wecome Tyler.

I'm pretty much the same here as Banjo-guy, I think the drain pipe mods are cool, and if I was doing 5 gallon batches over 1.05ish I might consider doing it, getting a pump, etc., but all I'm planning on doing are batches (mostly 3 gallons) where I can do it full volume no sparge BIAB style, and anything 5 gallons will be stuff like patersbiers, bitters, or milds that will below 1.05 and still fit with full volume.

But since I'm getting 80+% mash efficiency doing that the way I am now, and the couple of beers I've tried out of the 7 batches I've made so far are both excellent, I don't see any reason to fiddle with my mash & boil adding more "stuff" to it right now.

I have a long probe thermometer, and my mash temps down in the grain bed stay pretty stable, more stable then the temperature reading at the bottom sensor would suggest because the thermal mass of all the water being put in up front is significant. The sensor is just reading a thin layer near the burner, all that heat just works its way up through the mash and around the sides of the grain pipe, so although it might read a couple of degrees too high at the sensor after it fires up and kicks off, the actual mash is not getting too high. Stirring it once in a while is all I have needed to do, and I think that's really just helping my mash along by releasing starches and sugars from the grains more then because of mash temps.

Adding more stuff is right now for me is just more stuff to clean, fiddle with, maintain, etc. I'm all about simple. Simple is why I've actually made 7 AG batches since I got this, if it wasn't simple I'd still be doing mostly PMs and/or steep + extract.

The simplicity of the thing has turned this old former AG brewer that later turned into PM/Extract brewer back into a primary AG brewer.
bpgreen
Uber Brewer
Uber Brewer
Posts: 1966
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 9:50 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by bpgreen »

Welcome!

I've only done two batches and went from horrible efficiency to not so great efficiency. I'd like to start getting great (pie even good) efficiency. I've got a pump now, but maybe need the pipe mod (I replied to your recent post on Facebook).
bpgreen
Uber Brewer
Uber Brewer
Posts: 1966
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 9:50 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by bpgreen »

To expand on my last post, Tyler sells his drain pipe mod for $55 (shipping included anywhere in the US).

I just ordered one from him. I'm debating using it this weekend or waiting until my next brew to isolate what changes make the most difference.

I'd like to get better efficiency, and I think this will help. But I'd also like to get consistent efficiency. And I think this will help with that, as well.
Entropy_Brewing
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 8
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2018 1:37 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by Entropy_Brewing »

mashani wrote:
Banjo-guy wrote:Welcome to the borg. You’ve done some really great mods to the M and B.I’ve done three brews. All were 3 gallon biab. That’s all I plan on doing because I like the simplicity of it. Watching your videos makes want to follow your approach but I think I’ll keep it simple. I only need 2.5 gallon batches most of the time.
Yes, Wecome Tyler.

I'm pretty much the same here as Banjo-guy, I think the drain pipe mods are cool, and if I was doing 5 gallon batches over 1.05ish I might consider doing it, getting a pump, etc., but all I'm planning on doing are batches (mostly 3 gallons) where I can do it full volume no sparge BIAB style, and anything 5 gallons will be stuff like patersbiers, bitters, or milds that will below 1.05 and still fit with full volume.

But since I'm getting 80+% mash efficiency doing that the way I am now, and the couple of beers I've tried out of the 7 batches I've made so far are both excellent, I don't see any reason to fiddle with my mash & boil adding more "stuff" to it right now.

I have a long probe thermometer, and my mash temps down in the grain bed stay pretty stable, more stable then the temperature reading at the bottom sensor would suggest because the thermal mass of all the water being put in up front is significant. The sensor is just reading a thin layer near the burner, all that heat just works its way up through the mash and around the sides of the grain pipe, so although it might read a couple of degrees too high at the sensor after it fires up and kicks off, the actual mash is not getting too high. Stirring it once in a while is all I have needed to do, and I think that's really just helping my mash along by releasing starches and sugars from the grains more then because of mash temps.

Adding more stuff is right now for me is just more stuff to clean, fiddle with, maintain, etc. I'm all about simple. Simple is why I've actually made 7 AG batches since I got this, if it wasn't simple I'd still be doing mostly PMs and/or steep + extract.

The simplicity of the thing has turned this old former AG brewer that later turned into PM/Extract brewer back into a primary AG brewer.
I bought the unit with the same intentions, I already have a 15gallon electric system that I've over engineered and this was supposed to be my "simple" system. I can never leave well enough alone, and the tinkering is half the fun of brewing for me, so here we are :laugh I will say that I have been able to brew WAY more with this system. Like I mentioned I can plug it in on the patio in the summer, or kitchen in the winter and still hang out with the kids while I get a batch of beer in. The result has been an improvement in my beer and brew day not being a chore any longer.

I'm a big proponent of doing what works for you, there isn't a right or wrong way to brew as long as you are getting results that you enjoy consistently. Sounds like you've got a solid process nailed down!
Entropy_Brewing
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 8
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2018 1:37 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by Entropy_Brewing »

berryman wrote:Excellent Tyler, glad you came here and joined our forum The Beer Borg A small but good group of very knowable brewers with a lot of different ways of making beer. The M&B thread is just one of the many things discussed here. Check out the whole forum and looking forward to your insight on brewing.
Thanks for inviting me over! I've already started poking around the forum, as a result my work productivity has also dropped. Seems like lots of good info to try and absorb.
User avatar
John Sand
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 4310
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 9:01 pm
Location: Long Island NY

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by John Sand »

Welcome aboard Entropy. That's some very cool engineering.
Making beer and stew for the Zombie Apocalypse.
Never mind, there it is.
User avatar
berryman
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 3279
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 5:16 pm
Location: Western NY

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by berryman »

bpgreen wrote: I just ordered one from him. I'm debating using it this weekend or waiting until my next brew to isolate what changes make the most difference.
I think if were me, I would try another batch without it first to try isolate your problem first. Your numbers should be higher then what you are getting, my first batch was at 74% with just a pour back over but instead of a pitcher I already had a pump.
That said, yes I am also building the drain pipe mod for mine and with Tyler's help and have got most everything now to build one. I will tell you he really isn't making no money on this after buying the components and shipping, I am close to that number and building it myself, but I like to build stuff and can and have the time.
Happy Hound Brewery

“I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.”
― Thomas A. Edison
bpgreen
Uber Brewer
Uber Brewer
Posts: 1966
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 9:50 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by bpgreen »

berryman wrote:
bpgreen wrote: I just ordered one from him. I'm debating using it this weekend or waiting until my next brew to isolate what changes make the most difference.
I think if were me, I would try another batch without it first to try isolate your problem first. Your numbers should be higher then what you are getting, my first batch was at 74% with just a pour back over but instead of a pitcher I already had a pump.
That said, yes I am also building the drain pipe mod for mine and with Tyler's help and have got most everything now to build one. I will tell you he really isn't making no money on this after buying the components and shipping, I am close to that number and building it myself, but I like to build stuff and can and have the time.
I think that's my plan. Even without the pipe mod, I'm going to be doing two things differently this weekend. I'm using my Kitchenaid to mill the grains so I can mill them finely and with better control, and I'm going to use the pump to recirculate. Then I'l use the pipe mode on the next batch. Or maybe do one with the pump and mill the grains with the cereal killer (but I think I need to use a different drill; the one I have doesn't have enough torque) and then one with the pipe mod.
User avatar
berryman
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 3279
Joined: Tue Aug 20, 2013 5:16 pm
Location: Western NY

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by berryman »

Brian, years ago when I built and raced drag cars, I learned if you change too many things at a time you don't know what helped or hurt. One thing might be the greatest but the other thing might have not been so good. Just my thinking and I apply it to brewing
Happy Hound Brewery

“I have not failed. I've just found 10,000 ways that won't work.”
― Thomas A. Edison
Entropy_Brewing
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 8
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2018 1:37 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by Entropy_Brewing »

bpgreen wrote:
berryman wrote:
bpgreen wrote: I just ordered one from him. I'm debating using it this weekend or waiting until my next brew to isolate what changes make the most difference.
I think if were me, I would try another batch without it first to try isolate your problem first. Your numbers should be higher then what you are getting, my first batch was at 74% with just a pour back over but instead of a pitcher I already had a pump.
That said, yes I am also building the drain pipe mod for mine and with Tyler's help and have got most everything now to build one. I will tell you he really isn't making no money on this after buying the components and shipping, I am close to that number and building it myself, but I like to build stuff and can and have the time.
I think that's my plan. Even without the pipe mod, I'm going to be doing two things differently this weekend. I'm using my Kitchenaid to mill the grains so I can mill them finely and with better control, and I'm going to use the pump to recirculate. Then I'l use the pipe mode on the next batch. Or maybe do one with the pump and mill the grains with the cereal killer (but I think I need to use a different drill; the one I have doesn't have enough torque) and then one with the pipe mod.
I think I agree. I would run without the drain pipe and see if you can get things back up to where they should be. I'm not sure how you would crush grain in the Kitchenaid, but I'd be afraid you'll get them too fine. The grain basket on the mash and boil doesn't like really fine dust/bits and gets clogged up. I would the same mill you were before, maybe use some rice hulls, and pull a larger amount of water when you do a "drain and sparge". You mentioned you pulled about a quart, I'd go double that up to a full gallon and pour it back over the top and stir well. That should extract plenty of sugars from your grains. If it doesn't then it might be time to look into your mill set up.
Entropy_Brewing
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 8
Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2018 1:37 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by Entropy_Brewing »

berryman wrote:Brian, years ago when I built and raced drag cars, I learned if you change too many things at a time you don't know what helped or hurt. One thing might be the greatest but the other thing might have not been so good. Just my thinking and I apply it to brewing
It all makes so much sense now! I'm a drag racer as well, probably why I can't leave things along and am constantly screwing with everything. ;)
bpgreen
Uber Brewer
Uber Brewer
Posts: 1966
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 9:50 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by bpgreen »

Entropy_Brewing wrote: I think I agree. I would run without the drain pipe and see if you can get things back up to where they should be. I'm not sure how you would crush grain in the Kitchenaid, but I'd be afraid you'll get them too fine. The grain basket on the mash and boil doesn't like really fine dust/bits and gets clogged up. I would the same mill you were before, maybe use some rice hulls, and pull a larger amount of water when you do a "drain and sparge". You mentioned you pulled about a quart, I'd go double that up to a full gallon and pour it back over the top and stir well. That should extract plenty of sugars from your grains. If it doesn't then it might be time to look into your mill set up.
I've got a mill attachment for the Kitchenaid. I can actually grind to almost flour (there's an adjustment I could make and probably actually get it to make flour, but that's not what I use it for, so I leave it set as-is). I'm grinding it fairly fine, but also have some silicon mats that somebody else here posted about (Maybe mashani?) a while back. If I put a couple of those in the bottom, slightly offset from each other, they act as sort of strainers, so finely ground grains don't plug the basket. Since it takes longer to mill with the kitchenaid, I've already started that, so I can't do this batch with my cereal killer.
User avatar
mashani
mashani
mashani
Posts: 6743
Joined: Sat Aug 10, 2013 11:57 pm

Re: Mash and Boil for 250.00

Post by mashani »

Yeah, these little things (silicon mats)

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B078YQB3VB

I am layering 3 of them on the bottom and weighing them down. I find them easier to clean the a grain bag and they filter pretty nicely.

My mash efficiency with the thin BIAB style mashes seem to be greatly affected by the mash PH, the closer I've gotten to 5.2-5.3 range 10 minutes into the mash, the higher my mash efficiency has been. I still get good efficiency at 5.4 as well.

That's why I've been throwing the acid malt into my batches. The one time I screwed up the amounts, I was at 5.6, and that's when I had a lot less efficiency. Beer still tastes great, it just is a "lite" beer. I used the same base malt (crushed at the same time) in the next beer, but it was a darker grain bill that hit 5.4, and had more then 15% higher mash efficiency. It was the only thing I did different, and since I've stuck with trying to stay in that range as long as I hit it, I'm getting the better efficiency.
Post Reply