Page 1 of 1

Stove-top mashing

Posted: Mon Sep 23, 2013 11:29 pm
by jpsherman
I'm looking for those who mash on the stove-top as opposed to sticking the pot in a preheated oven.

I have an induction stove-top that can maintain mashing/steeping temps with low to medium-low heat, with the pot only partially on the burner.

Do I need to worry about carmelization with low heat?

Do I need a trivet to keep the grain bag off the bottom of the pot?

I ask this because I could do one pot SMEIBB on the stove-top, or use two pots to do the mash in the oven.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Mon Sep 23, 2013 11:44 pm
by mashani
How hot does the actual bottom of the pot (not the wort) get when the burner kicks on? And what about temperature stratification from bottom to top? (test it with water take temps both at bottom and top).

The reason I do it in the oven is that at least on my gas stove I get too much variation in temps top to bottom.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Mon Sep 23, 2013 11:54 pm
by jpsherman
It doesn't really seem to "kick-on" but run steadily. What I started doing was just position 1/2 or less of the pot over the active burner. This was sufficient to keep temps in range even with me constantly opening the lid to check temps. So the grain bag should not be sitting directly over the middle of the active burner.

I am still figuring out my technique and new equipment so its a bit by the seat of my pants but taking notes right now.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Tue Sep 24, 2013 10:58 am
by FrozenInTime
I have a pressure cooker with canning screen that sits on the bottom to keep the jars off the bottom. It works great. My glasstop stove goes on - off - on - off so I don't trust it to not burn the bottom. That's why I went to turkey fryer type burners.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Tue Sep 24, 2013 4:59 pm
by joechianti
I found a nice round cake cooling rack that fit in the bottom of my brew pot to keep the bag of grains from burning.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2013 2:11 pm
by jpsherman
Thanks a lot FiT and Joe, those both sound like great ideas. I will use whichever is cheaper or fits better in my pot!

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2013 4:36 pm
by swenocha
I used to put this in the bottom of my pot, but I found that it caught on my grain bag at times...

Image

Something like this would work better, me thinks...

Image

Or, as Joe says, a cake cooling rack.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2013 7:47 pm
by The_Professor
I have done a lot of step mashes just grains and water (no bag) in the pot. Whenever I apply heat I slowly stir the grains making sure they don't sit on the bottom of the pot. My understanding is that for BIAB it is best to have some way to keep the actual grain bag from sitting on the bottom of the pot. So long as nothing is really sitting on the bottom of the pot during heating I don't see any issue at mash temps.

Re: Stove-top mashing

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2013 8:34 pm
by swenocha
Not that this is really pertinent to your situation, in my electric turkey fryer, I use the fish basket, which works really great. I just drop the bag inside of the basket, and then when it's time to drain the grains and/or sparge, I hang the basket on the hook for the basket (unless my water levels are high for a 4-5 gallon... in that case I hang it above instead). Maybe a basket scenario would work in your brewpot?

Image